Day: March 14, 2012

#CRC12 Paper: Chapter 8 – Entrepreneurs

#CRC12logosmallChapter 8 of the Copyright Review Committee‘s Consultation Paper considers whether the Copyright and Related Rights Act, 2000 (also here) creates barriers to innovation by entrepreneurs (update: you can download a pdf of the Paper here (via DJEI) or here (from this site)).

Although the interests of rights-holders are central to copyright law, the law recognises other interests as well, and entrepreneurs feature on both sides of this balance: sometimes as rights-holders, but increasingly as internet start-ups seeking to develop novel methods of engagement with content. A properly balanced copyright system should seek not only to reward initial creativity but also to encourage follow-on innovation. Hence, as with the balance between rights-holders and users in the previous chapter, one of the main questions for the Review is whether the copyright balance between rights-holders and entrepreneurs now requires further amendment, in particular to incentivise innovation.

The chapter begins by considering the contribution which entrepreneurs make to innovation. They are a key source of the innovation identified in chapter 2, and some of the submissions argued that inflexibility in Irish and EU copyright regimes hinder innovation, and that access to and use of legal digital content ought to be made easier and more attractive in Ireland and Europe. The chapter therefore assesses the extent to which entrepreneurs can or should be able to take advantage of copyright exceptions for the purposes of innovation. Finally, the chapter examines whether it is possible or desirable to craft a specialist copyright adaptation exception for innovation.

Print is Dead; Long Live the Word (Britannica Stops the Presses) by Deven Desai


Print is Dead. Long Live the Word. Britannica Stops the Presses. Welcome to the Henry Blake cliche festival. CNN Money reports that after 244 years the print edition of Britannica will no longer be offered. As many may recall, one study indicated the Wikipedia was more accurate than Britannica

But let’s not obsess over print. … Today the print edition is $1395. … Digital divide and access to knowledge discussions can miss that the cost of the set would cover Internet access for 20 months. … Digital also is a dream for the look it up model. … Will folks pay for the online version at $70 per year? I would guess not.

So go with God, Britannica. Thank you for the years of service and enhancing my childhood. And congratulations on your new form. Like those in Good To Great, you have ditched the old method and seek to play in the new space. It is a bet, but it you are in the correct game and that is good.