the Irish for rights

Appeal overturns food review case

Irish News portico, via BBC website.Under the above headline, the BBC is reporting that “the Court of Appeal [in Northern Ireland] has quashed a controversial libel case, seen as a watershed for press freedom”. As already discussed on this blog (here, here and here) food critics writing restaurant reviews will usually be able to rely on the defence of fair comment. As I noted in an earlier post, the case arose out of a review of a Belfast pizzeria in the Irish News. According to the BBC report:

A £25,000 libel award was initially made to Goodfella’s pizza restaurant in Belfast, after a jury found the paper’s food critic’s review defamatory. The court has now ruled that the jury in the original trial had been misdirected on whether the opinions were defensible as fair comment.

Journalist Caroline Workman‘s review criticised staff, the quality of food and drink, and the smokey atmosphere. Ciarnan Convery, the owner of the business, brought the libel action in February, 2007, claiming that the article was defamatory, damaging and hurtful.

Lawyers for the paper had defended their criticism of the restaurant on the basis of justification and fair comment. Delivering judgment, Lord Chief Justice Sir Brian Kerr said: “Although I consider it likely that a properly directed jury would conclude that a sufficient factual substratum existed for the comment… I cannot be certain that this is so and I would therefore order a retrial.”

The full text of the judgment is available here and here.

Update other coverage (11 March 2008) Belfast Telegraph | BreakingNews.ie | Bloomberg | Canadian Press | ecademy | eircom.net | Food and Drink | Guardian | Ireland.com Breaking News | International Herald Tribune | Irish Examiner Breaking News | Irish Independent Breaking News | IOL | Media Law Prof Blog | New York Times Diner’s Journal | News Letter | O’Connall Street | Press Gazette | RTÉ News at 1 | Slugger O’Toole | UTV.

Update: further coverage (12 March and later): AFP | Belfast Telegraph here and here | Blurred Keys | Breitbart | Decanter | Eye on UK | Guardian | Irish News (sub req’d) here and here | Irish Independent (including an exterior night-time photo of the restaurant) | Irish Times (sub req’d) | Last Year’s Girl | Man O’ Law | New York Times | OUT-law.com | Salt Lake Tribune | Pocket Blog | Salut! | SFoodie | The Independent | The Wire | Times Online here and here | UPI.

My favourite comment (marginally ahead of the Guardian‘s wonderfully entertaining list of quotes from bad reviews) comes from Jay Rayner (food critic, whose weekly Observer column is part of my Sunday ritual) on the Guardian‘s comment is free blog site:

A la carte blanche

A notorious decision awarding libel damages to a restaurant for a bad review has been overturned. Quite right: critics must be free to criticise

It’s triple creme brulees all round! The Irish News has won its appeal against the £25,000 libel damages it was ordered to pay in 2007, over a damning review of a Belfast pizzeria by their restaurant critic. Those of us who earn not only our crust, but the rest of the loaf and the three courses that follow from reviewing restaurants may safely dip our quills in an inkwell overflowing with venom once more.

Or we would, were it not for the fact that none of us allowed this libel case to change the way we wrote in the first place. …

Restaurant criticism – indeed, any criticism – is just another form of journalism, and governed by exactly the same laws. As of today, there isn’t a law against writing a really, really bad review. It’s called fair comment, and yesterday’s ruling upheld that principle. Those of us who do the job know this. Many of us, myself included, cut our teeth on other beats. In my time, I’ve covered everything from murders to war crimes trials, race crime to mental health, and in all of those subjects, knowledge of the laws of libel comes in handy. Now that I write about restaurants, it’s pretty useful, too. This libel case has changed nothing.

For a substantial entrée to the issues, see Take one chef, add a dash of criticism, and leave to simmer (Daily Telegraph). For a similar, though less tasty, dish, see Calm down dear, it’s only my opinion! Michael Winner defends every critic’s right to be rude (Daily Mail).

8 Responses to “Appeal overturns food review case”

  1. […] Carroll has more. Another Irish case sparking interest across the globe is Goodfellas v Irish News, reported by Eoin O’Dell here (also discussed at Blurred Keys, The Fatalist, Salut! and the Illinois Business Law Journal; […]

  2. Eric Baglio says:

    Another Irish case sparking interest across the globe

  3. Mike Kelly says:

    Its been Reported by Eoin O’Dell

  4. Paul Kirk says:

    Another Irish case sparking

  5. Diane says:

    Critics need to be able to say what they think, we listen to them and they must not be affraid to say what they feel is right.

  6. DUI Attorney says:

    Food critics writing restaurant reviews, as long as they don’t go beyond their boundaries, can be of good help to anybody in a sense that they provide relevant information regarding a certain restaurant where people should go.

  7. […] section 20(1) provides for a defence of honest opinion, renaming and replacing the defence of fair comment. The plea in Hunter v Duckworth [2003] IEHC 81 (31 July 2003), dodged by the Supreme Court, was […]

  8. […] 20 Defamation Act, 2009 (also here). It is better to see the refreshingly open approach to the defence of fair comment at common […]

Leave a Reply



Me in a hatHi there! Thanks for dropping by. I'm Eoin O'Dell, and this is my blog: Cearta.ie - the Irish for rights.

"Cearta" really is the Irish word for rights, so the title provides a good sense of the scope of this blog.

In general, I write here about private law, free speech, and cyber law; and, in particular, I write about Irish law and education policy.


  • RSS Feed
  • RSS Feed
  • Subscribe via Email
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Archives by month

Categories by topic

My recent tweets

Blogroll (or, really, a non-blogroll)

What I'd like for here is a simple widget that takes the list of feeds from my existing RSS reader and displays it here as a blogroll. Nothing fancy. I'd love a recommendation, if you have one.

I had built a blogroll here on my Google Reader RSS subscriptions. Google Reader produced a line of html for each RSS subscription category, each of which I pasted here. So I had a list of my subscriptions as my blogroll, organised by category, which updated whenever I edited Google Reader. Easy peasy. However, with the sad and unnecessary demise of that product, so also went this blogroll. Please take a moment to mourn Google Reader. If there's an RSS reader which provides a line of html for the list of subscriptions, or for each RSS subscription category as Google Reader did, I'd happily use that. So, as I've already begged, I'd love a recommendation, if you have one.

Meanwhile, please bear with me until I find a new RSS+Blogroll solution




Creative Commons License

This blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. I am happy for you to reuse and adapt my content, provided that you attribute it to me, and do not use it commercially. Thanks. Eoin

Credit where it’s due

The image in the banner above is a detail from a photograph of the front of Trinity College Dublin night taken by Melanie May.

Others whose technical advice and help have proven invaluable in keeping this show on the road include Dermot Frost, Karlin Lillington, Daithí Mac Síthigh, and Antoin Ó Lachtnáin.

Thanks to Blacknight for hosting.