Contradictions in Defamation Cases « Strasbourg Observers

Contradictions in Defamation Cases

January 6, 2011

 

by Stijn Smet

Before its holiday break, the European Court of Human Rights released two judgments in defamation cases, Novaya Gazeta V Voronezhe v. Russia and Sofranschi v. Moldova. Both cases concern allegations of abuse and irregularities. While both judgments contain good elements, in my opinion they also reveal faulty reasoning on the part of the Court. Most interestingly, the judgments contradict each other on some crucial points. Thus one judgment provides alternatives to the shortcomings of the other.

 

Tags:

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *