Author: Eoin

Dr Eoin O'Dell is a Fellow and Associate Professor of Law at Trinity College Dublin.

Data Privacy: Three Cautionary Tales

| 3 Comments
| Digital Rights, Privacy

Irish Times image, via the Irish Times website.On front page of this morning’s Irish Times, Karlin Lillington writes

Garda powers of request for internet data to be widened

THE RANGE of criminal investigations for which the Garda will be able to request e-mail and internet data retained by internet service providers has been broadened by the Government. … Under the draft statutory instrument, retained data would include names of those who sent and received e-mails, computer addresses, the location of computer users, the times a user logged on and off a computer, and the size of files and e-mails sent and received, but not the content of e-mails.

…

Read More »

The Case of the Mistaken Flights

| 8 Comments
| advertising, Contract, Mistaken offers

An Aer Lingus Airbus A321 landing at London Heathrow Airport in 2007, via WikipediaLook up, it’s Aer Lingus
Aer Lingus used to know how to do public relations – in my youth a long time ago in a galaxy far far away, it had three very powerful advertising campaigns which had a profound effect on me. One used the Gallagher & Lyle song “Breakaway” (YouTube) featuring the lyric “breakaway, fly across your ocean / breakaway, time has come for you”. The second featured the musical tag line “Look up, it’s Aer Lingus, there’s a little piece of Ireland flyin’ by”, with a little girl playing in a field looking up at an Aer Lingus Boeing flying overhead – it gave rise to Aer Lingus’s most enduring slogan, which I have used at the head of this paragraph. And the third was called “You’re Home” (YouTube) and featured Gabriel’s Oboe; it never failed to induce a catch in the voice, a lump in the throat, and a tear in the eye. Judging by a controversy that has flared over the last day or two, however, they seem long since to have lost this knack for connecting with the Irish zeitgeist. Instead, they have flown into a tempest of controversy which they moved to abate only after two days of pressure amounting to a public relations debacle for the airline.…

Read More »

US Supreme Court upholds the constitutionality of the lethal injection

| 2 Comments
| Capital Punishment, Law, US Supreme Court

Death penalty gurney, via the NPR site.On the day when the President of the United States welcomes the Pope to the White House, the long-awaited decision of the US Supreme Court on the compatibility of the lethal injection with the Eighth Amendment to the US Constitution has been handed down. In Baze v Rees, the challenge failed by a vote of 7 to 2 and the decision below (217 S. W. 3d 207 (2007)) was upheld; but the 7 is a fractured majority (I have previewed this case here and here; for full analysis, see the ScotusWiki page on the case; for initial news reaction, see NPR).

Roberts CJ, joined by Kennedy and Alito JJ, concluded that Kentucky’s lethal injection protocol satisfies the Eighth Amendment. In their view, allowing a condemned prisoner to challenge a State’s execution method merely by showing a slightly or marginally safer alternative found no support in the Court’s cases, that it would embroil the courts in ongoing scientific controversies beyond their expertise, and that it would substantially intrude on the role of state legislatures in implementing execution procedures. As a consequence, they held that the petitioners had failed to demonstrate the necessary substantial risk of serious harm, and that Kentucky’s protocol did not constitute an unconstitutional “cruel and unusual” punishment.…

Read More »

Incitement to Anorexia

| 5 Comments
| advertising, Censorship, Freedom of Expression, US Supreme Court

Bodywhys logo, via the Bodywhys website.L’Assemblée nationale francaise (the lower house of the French parliament) yesterday passed a “Draft law aimed at fighting incitement to seek extreme thinness or anorexia” providing for fines of to €30,000 and terms of imprisonment of up to two years for inciting to “excessive thinness” and more if the incitement results in death (see Associated Press | Daily Telegraph | Guardian | International Herald Tribune here and here | Irish Independent | Irish Times | Media Law Prof Blog here and here | New York Times; update Volokh, including the French text of the Bill). The Bill will go before le Sénat (the upper house) next month. According to the Guardian, the Bill:

would bar any form of media, including websites, magazines and advertisers, from promoting extreme thinness, encouraging severe weight-loss or methods for self-starvation … [and] is specifically aimed at what French MPs called pro-anorexia “propaganda” websites … [which] support anorexia as a lifestyle choice rather than a medical disorder … The blogs and forums, which have developed in the US since 2000 and grown in France over the past two years, often include talk-boards frequented mainly by teenage girls and young women with advice on how to get through the pain of extreme hunger after eating a yoghurt a day, or how to hide extreme weight-loss from parents or doctors.

…

Read More »

The First Amendment is dead; long live the First Amendment

| 2 Comments
| Freedom of Expression

Alex Kozinski, via WCL.The First Amendment is dead, according to Judge Alex Kozinski (right) (official bio | articles | magazine profile | unofficial site | UTR BSG | wikpedia).

When AK shoots from the lip, life is never boring. One friend likes his fiercely libertarian instincts, another his mercurial contrarian attitudes – I have always been a fan of his provocative First Amendment scholarship and decisions (one of the classic articles on the doctrine of commercial speech is Kozinski and Stuart Banner “Who’s Afraid of Commercial Speech?” 76 Virginia Law Review 627 (1990) (pdf); see also their sequel “The Anti-History and Pre-History of Commercial Speech” 71 Texas Law Review 747 (1993) (pdf); summary here).

Last week, he made speech theory life very interesting indeed. Delivering an address at a Pepperdine University School of Law Sympoisum on Free Speech & Press in the Modern Age – Can 20th Century Theory Bear the Weight of 21st Century Demands?, AK argued that the First Amendment is dead! In a summary provided by Roger Alford on Opinio Juris (also Legal Blog Watch | First Amendment Law Prof Blog), in a speech entitled “The Late, Great First Amendment”, the essence of what AK had to say was that

in a day when Internet speech is not capable of suppression, the ability of the First Amendment to have a moderating effect is now gone.

…

Read More »

Say, what?

| 1 Comment
| Freedom of Expression, Media and Communications, prior restraint

Bits blog image from NYT website.From today’s Bits Blog on the New York Times site:

Newspapers Argue for First Amendment Right to Snoop on Readers

Usually, when people talk about the trade offs between privacy and freedom of the press, the argument is about whether the public has the right to know some fact about an individual’s personal life.

The newspaper industry is now arguing that the First Amendment protects its right to follow users around the Internet so it can charge higher prices on advertising.

This argument was made in a filing by Newspaper Association of America commenting on the Federal Trade Commission’s proposal that the companies involved in advertising that uses what is called behavioral targeting create a self-regulatory code that limits their use of sensitive information.

…

Read More »

Something must be done – II

| 4 Comments
| Media and Communications

Red flags, via the BBC websiteThe moral of the story in my previous post about cars being preceded by men carrying red flags is that fear of the new often leads to unnecessary regulation. For this reason, in the context of the internet, we need to be careful about over-reaction and over-regulation. In particular, we now have, in Ireland, a multiplicity of red-flags around the internet, and I wonder whether they are all really necessary.

In November 1999 – arising out of the public debates surrounding the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act, 1998 (also here) and the publication of the Report of the Working Group on the Illegal and Harmful Use of the Internet in July 1998 – the Internet Service Providers Association of Ireland (ISPAI) established the Internet Child Pornography Hotline. It is now part of InHope (the International Association of Internet Hotlines) and of InS@fe, a europe-wide network of internet safety awareness bodies funded by the EU, which organises for example an annual Safer Internet Day (this year, it was 12 February last).

makeITsecure booklet cover, via their site.Soon thereafter, the Internet Advisory Board (IAB) was established by the Minister for Justice Equality and Law Reform in February 2000, with a general remit to supervise a system of self regulation by the Irish ISP industry and to pomote awareness of internet safety, particularly with regard to children.…

Read More »

© cearta.ie 2025. Powered by WordPress